Domino's and Subway in a War Neither is Likely to Win



The war between Domino's Pizza and Subway escalated as Domino's president David Brandon set fire on national TV to a Cease & Desist letter from Subway lawyers.

Domino's recent ad campaign trumpets an independent taste test that says consumers preferred Domino’s new oven baked sandwiches over Subway's by a margin of two-to-one. Subway wants the campaign pulled.

(Hey, Subway, have you heard of YouTube? Or The Way Back Machine?) Make a big enough stink and the ad you want to ban is sure to spread virally. And nothing that's ever been online really disappears if you know where to look!

Brandon says Domino's got approval for its claims from its own lawyers and those of every network that ran the campaign. "The requirements are significant and we passed all of them."

Times are tough, and market share is gold. Challenge ads are nothing new - Avis challenged Hertz decades ago, and Miller challenged Bud (or did Bud challenger Miller?)

Yet, when a company can't succeed unless it trashes another company, they don't always get the desired result.

If Subway makes enough noise, Domino's could end up winning consumer support - and if that happens, the ad Domino's ad could go viral.

More likely, consumers will not care, or will forget who trashed whom, or who won. It's quite possible that people will figure the Domino's test was rigged anyway. That's nothing but a no-win situation all around.

And marketers take note: Domino's v Subway or vice versa is not at all in the spirit of the Obama era.

You are so right...I just can't stand one company bashing another; either you like your product and talk about its charms or you don't. Just don't try to convince me to buy your product by being nasty to someone else's product. Where's the integrity?

If Domino's did not make such crappy pizza and Papa John's were not killing their market, there would be no need for Domino's to get into the sandwich market.

j.

Linda wonders about "integrity" between competitors?

Say what?

No such animal.

That is why a good number of countries do not allow comparative ads or even, in some cases, even mentioning in any way, shape or form, your competitor.

j.

I feel that Domino's had the right to advertise they way they did. It has sparked a fun battle.