Follow me on
Twitter

Services
Bio
Contact
What Works Now
NEW Expanded Edition
PRESS RELEASES FROM HELL and How to Fix Them
The Traditional Press Release Is Dead! The Made-for-the-Internet Release is News Now.
Buy this Report.
REALITY PR STRATEGY: Everything You Need to Know to Get Free (or Really Cheap) Publicity Now. Before you spend another dime on PR, Buy this Report.


Blogger Sued for $20 Million for Calling Company a Scammer

summons.pngLeslie Richard, owner of the small home-based eco-fashion business, is being sued for $20 million over a blog post.

Richard was contacted by Vision Media Television, a production company based in Boca Raton, FL, who said they wanted to include her and her clothing store in a segment on eco fashion. It would be seen, they told her, by 84 million people, on PBS, CNN, and all over Europe.

It all sounded great until VMT asked for almost $26,000 to cover production fees and travel costs for filming. Richard thought it sounded fishy, and she started doing some investigating.

She learned that they're not affiliated with PBS or CNN. In fact, PBS includes a disclaimer in the FAQs on their website that reads in part: "PBS wishes to clarify that it is not associated with and does not endorse, distribute programming for, review underwriting for or otherwise have any business relationship with the following production companies: VM Television, Vision Media Television..."

In a post titled Scam Taking Advantage of Green Businesses, Richard detailed what had happened, and included some of the emails that had been exchanged. In July, Vision Media responded with a lawsuit. They objected to her use of the word “scam.”

A major issue the case brings up is that bloggers First Amendment rights are not as clear as those of mainstream media. A bully like Vision Media counts on a lone blogger not having the resources to fight a lawsuit, even a frivolous one like this one.

The posts of many bloggers are shedding light on the situation, and that always helps because bullies count on having their victims turn tail and run.

Over the past several years, Media Bloggers Association has offered legal support and successfully resolved scores of similar cases. MBA's website says it soon will offer affordable liability insurance to its members, along with media law training.


Categories: Blog Legal Issues
BL Ochman | Aug 21 08 7:30 | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Wow! This is the first case we've seen like this on a small blogger. I too am "guilty" of calling out unethical companies myself and never imagined that they'd have the ability to sue over it if they are indeed pretty "scammy". I hope this woman doesn't get burned by that awful company. They're honestly doing themselves a big disservice. The more bloggers and media outlets that pick up this story, the worse they look.

Posted by: Nick Stamoulis at August 22, 2008 12:20 AM

Nick - unfortunately, it's far from the first and it won't be the last.

That's exactly why I'm posting about it - making their actions public is the best way to show who they really are.

Posted by: BL Ochman at August 22, 2008 7:27 AM

BL, in the pre-Internet days, I complained about a company to the Better Business Bureau. I soon received a letter from the "scammer" company, threatening to sue me for libel! Of course they never did.

Posted by: Donna Papacosta at August 22, 2008 8:28 AM

What's also amazing here are the "anonymous" comments that are clearly being posted by this company. A clear lack of transparency and attempt at deception coupled with their general business practices appear to be only making the blogger's case stronger.

I have also been contacted by companies like these several times. The first couple of times I was as outraged as this blogger was. Now, I'm able to sniff out this BS sales approach quickly and dispose of the call.

Just think... most of the company's problems regarding their integrity and ethics could have been avoided if they simply changed their sales pitch and were honest about the "paid advertisement" nature of their program.

Posted by: Sean Cheyney at August 22, 2008 9:56 AM

This is a very interesting case to read about. I think it's great that they will soon be offering affordable liability insurance.

Posted by: Recruiting Services at August 22, 2008 11:12 AM

Quite scary. I would love to know how this turns out.

Posted by: Susan at August 24, 2008 10:06 AM

I've blogged about bad companies many times and posted about others on message boards but I'm always careful to avoid terms like "scam" or "fraud". As long as what you say about them is true they can't sue you for libel and you can expose them to your hearts content but as soon as you use the S or F words you open yourself up for a lawsuit that doesn't require them to prove libel to win.

Posted by: Ventibate at August 24, 2008 11:47 PM

I'm going to be writing a post about the ad companies that in my opinion screw bloggers over.
And I hope someone tries to sue me for writing the truth.Publicity never killed anyone.But I'm really just writing it because I have already written these companies to no response.So I just want to save people from running these ads for FREE because if you don't get paid that is what it is a rip off.
Thanks great blog.

Posted by: John Sullivan at August 26, 2008 5:46 AM

My husband is being sued over his blog too.
Long story but basically a defimation of character suit, read here: http://sawatch.wordpress.com
His lawyers told him this week that they have learned that bloggers have the same defimation rules as any print publication...therefore because he sited all the doings of this particular company & all the links were correct, it is a no-brainer & the suit will most likely be dropped.
Needles to say, it has popped his enthusiasm for writing - and he is great if I do say so myself. I hope to get him back on the road to self expression once this blows over.

Posted by: Jen Harris at September 11, 2008 2:42 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)






Email this story to a friend







TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.whatsnextonline.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/4336

Search


Join the What's Next Blog mailing list
Email:

Contact: BL (at) whatsnextonline (dot) com
212.369.8312


blog advertising


About BL Ochman
BL Ochman
Blogger, social media strategy consultant to Fortune 500 companies, and sought-after corporate speaker B.L. Ochman heads the creative team of whatsnextonline.com. She also publishes the Ethics Crisis blog for SRF Global Translations


Poll ID 0 does not exist.



top 25 marketing blog

B.L.'s flickr photos








    Categories
    Ad targeting
    Advertainment
    Advertisement
    Advertising Campaigns
    Alternative Marketing
    Awards
    B.L. Ochman
    Benny Bix
    Best Practices
    Blog Advertising
    Blog Bashing
    Blog ethics
    Blog Legal Issues
    Blog Post From Hell
    Blog Software
    Blogging and Moblogging
    Bloomberg for President
    Books
    Business Communications
    Business Ethics
    Buzz
    Case Studies
    Clueless ad agencies
    Commentary
    Conferences
    Corporate_Blogging
    Cross Media
    Customer Service Issues
    Dead Tree Journalism
    Design Train Manifesto
    Digital Journalism
    Don't Believe the Hype
    E-Commerce
    Email Marketing
    Entertainment
    Ethics Crisis
    Events
    Fatblogging
    Folksonomy
    Fun
    Global Business
    Heard on the street
    Hurricane Katrina
    Internet
    Internet PR
    Internet strategy
    Interviews
    Leaders
    Marketing Strategy
    Media Relations
    Memes
    Mike Bloomberg for President
    Multi-Media Advertising
    Must-Read Articles
    Needs a Blog
    New Products
    News
    Nikon D80 Blogger Program
    Nikon D80 Blogger Program
    Nonsense and Parodies
    Pawfun.com
    Peer to peer
    Peer-to-peer
    People to Watch
    Pet Food News
    Podcasting
    Politics
    PR Cluelessness
    President Barak Obama
    Press Release From Hell
    Product Placements
    Promotions
    Public Relations
    Publishing
    Reality Marketing
    Reports
    Resources
    RSS
    Satire
    Search Engine Marketing
    Second Life
    Shameless Self Promotion
    Social Media
    Social Media Marketing
    Studies
    Surveys
    Technology
    Thought Leaders
    Top Bloggers Essential Research Tools
    Trends
    Up and Comers
    Up Your Budget Treasure Hunt
    User Generated Content
    Venture Capital
    Video Contests
    Viral Marketing
    Virtual Marketing
    Vlogs
    Word of Mouth
    Worst Practices

    Powered by
    Movable Type 3.31