Follow me on
Twitter

More Information

NEW Expanded Edition

PRESS RELEASES FROM HELL and How to Fix Them
The Traditional Press Release Is Dead! The Made-for-the-Internet Release is News Now.
Buy this Report.

REALITY PR STRATEGY: Everything You Need to Know to Get Free (or Really Cheap) Publicity Now. Before you spend another dime on PR, Buy this Report.

Bloggers Are Not Reporters and Other Blog Bashing From Report on Excellence in Journalism

The Project for Excellence in Journalism's annual report on American media engages in quite a bit of blog bashing, including its lament that as the number of MSM reporters erodes:

"we may well rely more on citizens to be sentinels of one another - whether it's soldiers blogging from Baghdad or young radio reporters covering local towns.... The worry is not the wondrous addition of citizen media," the report maintains, "but the decline of full-time, professional monitoring of powerful institutions."

The report complains that

"Among blogs, there is little of what journalists would call reporting (study finds reporting in just 5% of postings)."

(They don't explain how they calculated that.)

However, the report fails to note that MSM sucks at monitoring powerful institutions. An excerpt from the White House correspondent Helen Thomas' forthcoming book, Watchdogs of Democracy? The Waning Washington Press Corps and How It Has Failed the Public. Says:

Of all the unhappy trends I have witnessed--conservative swings on television networks, dwindling newspaper circulation, the jailing of reporters and "spin"--nothing is more troubling to me than the obsequious press during the run-up to the invasion of Iraq. They lapped up everything the Pentagon and White House could dish out--no questions asked.

Reporters and editors like to think of themselves as watchdogs for the public good. But in recent years both individual reporters and their ever-growing corporate ownership have defaulted on that role. Ted Stannard, an academic and former UPI correspondent, put it this way: "When watchdogs, bird dogs, and bull dogs morph into lap dogs, lazy dogs, or yellow dogs, the nation is in trouble."

Bloggers have frequently raised questions and reported stories that later made their way into mainstream media, including news about Trent Lott, Dan Rather, Abu Ghraib and others that the report doesn't mention.

Discussing media trends, the report notes that both Google and Yahoo! News aggregate content from other media, which is likely to begin charging the services for content in 2006. That's clearly going to be a court battle.

While Google culls from 4,500 news sources, they note, Yahoo is focusing more heavily on the judgment of six sources -- AP, Reuters, Agence France-Presse (AFP), the Los Angeles Times, USA Today and the Christian Science Monitor. Users also can select their own sources from a list of 14. (Yahoo also includes blog posts in its news search results.) Says the report:

If Google News is about mining the Web for maximum depth, in other words, Yahoo News is more about navigating it within clearer limits for maximum choice.

Posted by B.L. Ochman

Categories: B.L. Ochman, Blog Bashing, Blogging and Moblogging, Dead Tree Journalism, Digital Journalism, News, Reports

BL Ochman | Mar 13 06 5:37 | TrackBack (0)

Comments

B.L., the MSM has to decide what it wants to be.

Yes, there is a place for professionals who spend the time and resources to "play watchdog." The strength of the "pajama pirates" or whatever it is we'll be called next is that we can cross disciplines and opine about trends. Opinion matters in blogs, because this is a social exercise. It is when we bring together multiple perspectives, viewpoints, and sources that we can reveal truth.

Yes, 95% of blog posts don't do actual "reporting." But they sure as hell can analyze the reporting that is done, synthesize from several sources to reach a better understanding, and hold the MSM accountable. That's what social technology does better than anything else, and to expect us all to be independent volunteer news bureaus is absurd.

Posted by: Ike at March 13, 2006 6:50 PM

At least bloggers tell you their opinion. MSM masks theirs in so-called "objectivity."

Posted by: B.L. Ochman at March 13, 2006 11:44 PM

I'll go you one better. The MSM "markets" theirs as "objectivity," then smears marketers and ad people as sleazy, manipulative, and impure.

Posted by: Ike at March 14, 2006 4:15 PM

Email this story to a friend

TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.whatsnextonline.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/3007

Search

Contact: BL (at) whatsnextonline (dot) com
212.369.8312

RSS Feed

blog advertising

About BL Ochman

Blogger, social media strategy consultant to Fortune 500 companies, and sought-after corporate speaker B.L. Ochman heads the creative team of whatsnextonline.com. She also publishes the Ethics Crisis blog for SRF Global Translations

Poll ID 0 does not exist.