Sure there are success stories among the big companies that have dipped their toes in the social media water. But the vast majority of giant companies are still absolutely terrified of social media, Given that even cornflakes are part of called social media these days, that’s a lot of fear.
The Mommy Meganiche Strikes
It seems doubtful that Motrin was anything but fearful when a swarm of thousands of mommy bloggers and Twitter moms attacked their ad about baby slings last weekend. Motrin took down the ad within hours, substituting a humorless email that Seth Godin described as “the carefully crafted non-statement of a committee.” And a missed opportunity to connect to the mommy meganiche to build bridges.
Before you could say “pain in the neck” someone calling themselves “imperfectparent” had posted a funny “Motrin commercial alternative” on YouTube, where it’s had 8,000 views in just one day. At least someone had a sense of humor!
Instead of responding with their own good-natured and humorous response, Motrin has remained deadly serious, ending up looking rather silly.
Fred Goes Swimming
It’s easy to see how social media can confuse CMOs and CEOs alike, not to mention ad agencies. Fred, a 15 year-old boy who sounds like he inhaled helium, has had 11 million views of one his recent “Fred Goes Swimming“, and 70,000 comments. A video featuring nothing more than a pair of “daft hands” gets nearly 26 million downloads and 83,000 comments, and a video of the young men belonging to those hands eating cornflakes quickly got 17,000 views.
It’s doubtful that most corporate types even know that these videos, or sites like YTMND and 4chan exist, let alone that they get more pageviews in a week than many corporate sites get in a decade.
Niche Bites Man
YTMND stands for “You’re the man now, dog”, a line Sean Connery said in the movie Finding Forrester in 2000. The site, supported entirely by Google ads, hosts tens of thousands of user-created pages that combine a background image, a sound clip, and rudimentary animation. It gets millions of unique visitors a month, more than 100,000 of whom have contributed pages.
Big brands: you’re the man now, dog, and the woman. You need to engage in some serious research and school yourself on what is happening online that doesn’t come from the usual suspects – you and your corporate buds.
Time to try candor, humor, real dialog. And to meganiche or be niched.
UPDATE, November 20: I’m going to join Jim Turner at One By One Media Blog in his challenge to Motrin, Johnson & Johnson and McNeil Consumer Healthcare – the marketing team for Motrin – asking them to respond to this post to prove that they have begun to monitor social media. And to prove that they are, in fact, willing to join the conversation and to leave a comment on this post within the next day or two. I would very much, and respectfully, like to hear your point of view, and I am sure my readers would too.
Why Big Companies Are So Scared of Social Media: Cornflakes
Tags: , #motrinmoms, 4chan, BL Ochman, Cereal, Daft Hands, Fred Goes Swimming, future of the Internet, meganiche, mommy niche, Motrin ad, Motrin Ad Alternative, Seth Godin, social media, social media marketing, YTMND